Skip to main content

LPGA Hall of Fame Criteria Must Be Changed!

How hard is it to qualify for the LPGA Hall of Fame? If you look at the recent statistics, it's next to impossible.

First let us take a look at the LPGA Tour criteria for entry into the Hall of Fame.


        1 - Must be/have been an "active" LPGA Tour member for 10 years.    

  1. 2 - Must have won/been awarded at least one of the following - an LPGA major championship, the Vare Trophy or Rolex Player of the Year honors; and 
  2. 3 - Must have accumulated a total of 27 points, which are awarded as follows - one point for each LPGA official tournament win, two points for each LPGA major tournament win and one point for each Vare Trophy or Rolex Player of the Year honor earned.

Okay. So you think that doesn't look too difficult to achieve? Well look again.

Only one player has met the above criteria in the last eleven years, Inbee Park.

Image result for inbee park LPGA Hall of fame
Inbee Park holds up the Vare Trophy she won in 2015, which gave her enough points for HOF induction.

To get inducted into the World Golf Hall of Fame, it is much easier.
A player needs just 15 wins from any of the major tours that participate in the Rolex Rankings (LPGA, Ladies European Tour, Korean LPGA, Japan LPGA, Australian Ladies Professional Golf). There are other ways to get in including winning two Major Championships. The men on the PGA Tour have similar qualifications for induction.

So why make it so difficult for LPGA induction?


If anything, shouldn't the criteria be more difficult for the men? After all most men seem to play 25 to 30 years before moving on to the Champions Tour.


The LPGA life for women, for obvious reasons (starting up a family, etc.) is much shorter. They have less time to accumulate points.


The one great thing about the LPGA criteria is that you don't have to be 50 years old (like the World Golf Hall of Fame) to become a member. I think that is great for the fans who could come out to see a Hall of Fame member while they are still active. The only problem is that only three LPGA Hall of Fame members are active players. Two of those players (Juli Inkster and Karrie Webb) are playing a very limited schedule. 


Why is it so difficult to accumulate 27 points? Is it that these ladies aren't good enough? No! Just the opposite. The LPGA players are stronger now than anytime in their history. There is so much depth, that it has become impossible for one player to dominate. In 2017, the LPGA played 34 tournaments and had 22 different winners. This year they have played nine tournaments and have had nine different winners. 


Laura Davies has 25 points and has been two points short of induction for quite some time. She has won over 50 tournaments worldwide and deserves to be put in the LPGA Hall of Fame NOW, not later on by the veteran's committee!


Lorena Ochoa has enough points but didn't put in the 10 years. She did it in less than ten years. Isn't that an even greater achievement? She also needs to be put in now.


In the last eleven years, 28 baseball players have been inducted into the Hall of Fame in Cooperstown. How can it be that the LPGA has had just one?

Commissioner Michael Whan has said in the past that he doesn't want to change the criteria. I have the utmost respect for Mr. Whan who has done so many wonderful things since being appointed Commissioner of the LPGA. It is time for him to revisit this subject and make the necessary changes.


UPDATE: 4/29/18 

I have received several e-mails asking what I though the solution might be.
I would do the following:

1- Lower the points needed for induction from 27 to 25.

2- Eliminate the 10 year rule.
3- Set up a committee made up of retired players and media. Put out a ballot each year with each member of the committee allowed to write down 2 names they think should be inducted (they don't have to write any names if they don't think anyone is worthy). If a player gets 75% of the votes they are inducted (similar to baseball). 

The first year's ballot should include the names of Laura Davies, Lorena Ochoa, Cristie Kerr, and Yani Tseng. If not voted in the names can be put on again the following year. If a player does not get voted in, then will always have the chance of getting in automatically via #1 above. 


This is not a perfect solution and a fine tuning may be needed.



This Week's Trivia Question:  (For those who missed it earlier)
There are 29 LPGA members that currently reside in the state of California. That ranks second most on the LPGA Tour. Florida is #1. How many current LPGA players reside in the state of Florida?
A) 33       B) 48       C) 63



Comments

  1. 25 points seems reasonable and eliminate the 10 year rule. I don't think there needs to be multiple inductees annually but as you've mentioned, there are 2 players who are legends on the game and not in the HOF. Laura Davies and Lorena Ochoa.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

ISPS Handa Women's Australian Open Preview & Pairings

After a one week break, the LPGA travels to the continent of Australia for the ISPS Women's Australian Open. This tournament has a history of very close finishes. Who could forget the 2012 finish, where Jessica Korda won a 6 player playoff? The following year Jiyai Shin and Yani Tseng battled it out down the stretch, with Jiyai coming out on top by 2 strokes. Last year nine players finished within 3 strokes of each other, with Karrie Webb taking home the trophy.




This will be tournament #3 of 33 official tournaments on the 2015 LPGA schedule.

Here are the key details:

Course:  The Royal Melbourne Golf Club
Location:  Melbourne, Austrailia
Defending Champion:  Karrie Webb
Winning Score:  71-69-68-68 = 276 (-12)

Final Field:  156 players
Par: 38/35 = 73
Yardage:  6,479
Purse:  $1,200,000

My strength of field rating is a weak 48%. Just 25 of the top 50 players on the LPGA Priority List, and 11 of the top 25 players from the Rolex Rankings, will be teeing it up. Among the missing this w…

LPGA Player Profile - Natalie Gulbis

With the LPGA taking a one week break before resuming its schedule in the state of Texas, I want to take this opportunity to do my fifth player profile.

The player I have chosen this time around, may very well be in the twilight of her career, but has been a crowd favorite for many years. I have chosen:

NATALIE GULBIS


Born: 1/7/83 (34 years old)
Hometown: Sacramento Calif.
Resides: Lake, Las Vegas, Nev.
Rookie Year: 2002



Natalie has won once on the LPGA tour:

2007 Evian Masters

 Natalie has had many of her best finishes in Major Championships!

Best Finishes in Major Championships:

ANA Inspiration - Finished 3rd in 2006KPMG Women's PGA Championship - Finished 5th in 2005U.S. Women's Open - Finished 4th in 2005Ricoh British Open - Finished 9th in 2013The Evian Championship - Finished 52nd in 2013 (It was not a Major Championship when she won this event).

Career Stats:

318 career starts237 cuts made (74.5%)37 top tens (11.6%)Has $4,892,233 in career earnings through the 2016 season (57…

LPGA Reshuffles 2018 Priority List

The LPGA had its first reshuffle of its Priority List this week. While most of the players moved up or down a few insignificant spots, there were some very significant moves also.

The Priority List is what is used to fill the required amount of spots for any given tournament. Without me getting into the categories, which is potentially confusing, here is a brief explanation. Most full field events have a field of 144 players. Usually 140 of the players come from the Priority List ranking. Two players are Monday qualifiers, and 2 more are sponsor exemptions. So to keep it simple, if your Priority Rating is #150, you have to hope that 10 players decide not to play, or you are probably not getting into the field.


The following players made some of the biggest jumps in this week's reshuffle (and by getting into the top 100 become part of my weekly field rating):
Bronte Law - 108 to 86
Amy Olson - 112 to 88
Nasa Hataoka - 116 to 92
Caroline Inglis - 126 to 93
Hee Young Park - 106 to 94
Mariajo…

Most Popular Photos of the Year - 2017

1/9/18 - Bonus pics added at bottom of this page!


As many of my readers know, my wife and I go to quite a few LPGA tournaments each year. Since 2010 we have gone to over 50 events, including two in Scotland (St. Andrews being our favorite), and the last 8 Canadian Opens.

I do all the writing on here (my wife who is a teacher, is my proofreader), while my wife Cindy does most of the picture taking. Neither of us are professional photographers, but once in a while we get lucky and capture a moment that is very popular with my viewers.

Below I have reposted the most popular photos of 2017. I based this on the number of website hits, and the number of comments each photo received. Some came as quite a surprise to me, as when they were taken I was not expecting such a reaction.

#18
#17
#16
#15
#14
#13
#12
#11
#10
#9

LPGA Qualifying Tournament 2018 Final Stage - The Q-Series

The final stage of the LPGA qualifying tournament, the Q-Series, will begin this week.
A field of 102 players will be teeing it up.

At the 2017 CME Group Tour Championship, the LPGA first announced that Q-Series will replace LPGA Qualifying School Final Stage, which was previously held annually in Daytona Beach, Florida. 

Instead of 90 holes like the old Final Stage, the new Q-Series will be 144 holes. Players will compete in two, four-day tournaments with cumulative scores over the eight rounds for a $150,000 purse, which will be distributed at the end of the eight rounds.

The LPGA will debut the new Q-Series at the historic Pinehurst Resort in Pinehurst, North Carolina, which has hosted several prestigious tournaments including the 2014 U.S. Women’s Open. 
The first week of the LPGA Q-Series presented by Blue Cross and Blue Shield of North Carolina will be played on the George and Tom Fazio-designed Pinehurst Course No. 6 from Oct. 24-27, while the Q-Series will conclude on the Rees Jon…

U.S. Women's Open Preview, Pairings, and More

Before I get started on this week's tournament, let me give a big congratulations to Minjee Lee for winning the LPGA Volvik Championship. Minjee's final round -4 under par 68, was good enough to win by one stroke over runner-up In Kyung Kim.


This week the LPGA travels to the state of Alabama for the playing of the U.S. Women's Open Conducted by the USGA. This is the second Major Championship of the 2018 season.

Sung Hyun Park will be trying to successfully defend the title she won last year at Trump National Golf Club by two strokes over Hye Jin Choi.



This will be tournament #14 of 33 on this year's LPGA schedule. It is also the 2nd of five Major Championships to be held this year.

Course:  Shoal Creek
Location:  Shoal Creek, Alabama
Defending Champion:  Sung Hyun Park
Winning Score:  73-70-67-67 = 277 (-11)

Final Field:  156 players
Cut: Top 60 and ties
Par:  36/36 = 72
Yardage:  6,732
Purse:  $5,000,000



My strength of field rating is a mighty 87% (down from 91% last year). The re…

LPGA Player Profile: Azahara Munoz

It has been a while since I did my last LPGA player profile.

The player I have chosen this week is the very popular:


Azahara Munoz



Born:  11/19/87 (30 years old)
Hometown:  San Pedro del Alcantara, Spain
Resides:  Jupiter, Fla.
Rookie Year: 2010
2017 Earnings:  $286,417 (63rd)

She has won once on the LPGA tour:

2012 Sybase Match Play Championship
Best finishes in Major Championships: ANA Inspiration - Finished 7th in 2014KPMG Women's PGA Championship - Finished 4th in 2014U.S. Women's Open - Finished 19th in 2010Ricoh Women's British Open - Finished 12th in 2014The Evian Championship - Finished 19th in 2013


Career Stats: 202 career starts175 cuts made (86.6%)38 top tens (18.8%)Has $4,894,331 in career earnings. (61st on the all time LPGA career money list)


Other career highlights: Posted a career high 10 top ten finishes in 2014First Spaniard to win the Louise Suggs Rolex Rookie of the Year award in 2010Turned professional in 2009 and qualified for the LPGA tour in her first atte…